Health organizations from Canada and various provinces are urging the federal government to intervene and prevent Alberta from permitting doctors to work in both the public and private health care systems.
This adjustment is made possible by the Health Statutes Amendment Act, 2025 (No. 2), commonly referred to as Bill 11, which is set to take effect on Tuesday.
“[Bill 11 is] the most significant threat to health care since the introduction of the Canada Health Act in 1984,” stated Jason MacLean, chair of the Canadian Health Coalition, during a press conference held in Ottawa on Monday.
The coalition plans to organize rallies in 30 locations across Canada as part of their Day of Action on Tuesday. This will be followed by 50 town hall meetings this fall as part of their nationwide campaign opposing the bill.
MacLean expressed concerns that the changes brought by the bill would lead to unequal access to health care. He noted that when physicians are allowed to practice in both systems, resources often shift towards the private sector, resulting in longer wait times in the public system.
He urged federal Health Minister Marjorie Michel to take action before other provinces might adopt similar measures.
“We are perplexed by the federal government’s silence on this matter. It’s a significant issue for the entire nation,” he remarked.
“It’s clear that what unfolds in Alberta will not remain confined to Alberta.”
Bill 11 was proposed and approved in the Alberta legislature during the fall 2025 session, enabling doctors to apply for the opportunity to work in both public and private sectors.
To qualify for dual practice in Alberta, physicians must fulfill a mandated number of hours in the public system. Currently, family doctors are not permitted to operate in both systems.
The province has indicated that surgeries under the dual-practice initiative are unlikely to commence until later in the fall, as physicians must first receive government approval. Applications will begin in mid-September.
Maddison McKee, press secretary for Alberta’s Minister of Hospital and Surgical Health Services, Adriana LaGrange, informed CBC News that the province is evaluating nearly 400 expressions of interest from physicians regarding the new dual-practice option received over the summer.
“This will assist us in assessing interest, understanding which specialists are considering dual practice, and preparing for the formal application process,” she noted.
“Applications will be assessed to ensure that eligibility criteria and governmental requirements are met, including public surgery hour commitments, monitoring, and new reporting obligations.”
Province maintains dual practice is permissible
McKee dismissed the Canadian Health Coalition’s concerns regarding Alberta’s shift towards a U.S.-style health care system as mere “fearmongering.” She asserted that dual practice does not breach the Canada Health Act.
“Our focus is on maintaining a robust public system and ensuring that Albertans do not have to pay out of pocket for necessary medical care—a commitment we have made under our Public Health Care Guarantee,” she stated.
“Enhancing access through dual practice does not detract from this; it complements it. This is not a binary issue; it’s about providing Albertans with more options.”
Earlier this month, Michel expressed her concerns regarding Bill 11 to the Toronto Star. On Monday, her spokesperson, Alexandre Bergeron, stated that the federal government was working with Alberta on any changes “that respects their jurisdiction to explore innovative methods to enhance access and care while strengthening the public, universal health care system.”
“Minister Michel is engaging in focused discussions with her counterpart to ensure that access to medically necessary care and the foundational principles of the public system are upheld,” he added.
“A collaborative approach between our governments has consistently yielded positive outcomes for all Albertans, and we will persist in that direction.”
On July 24, the federal government sent a letter to the province confirming its review of the regulations and the ministerial order issued on June 18, emphasizing the need for continued collaboration between both levels of government.
Bergeron mentioned that Ottawa is in close communication with the province to address any potential negative impacts on the public system and to ensure that changes adhere to the principles of the Canada Health Act.

