When Jeff Warner loaded his 1,711-pound pumpkin onto a trailer for the Port Elgin Pumpkinfest earlier this month, he was aware that winning a top award wasn’t assured. However, the Englehart, Ont., farmer hoped for a chance at victory.
Unfortunately, he was disqualified from the giant vegetable competition due to a soft spot on the pumpkin.
“About a week prior to harvesting, I noticed a small soft spot on [the pumpkin] — roughly the size of a loonie,” Warner explained to As It Happens guest host Dave Seglins.
He understood that the competition had rigorous rules concerning the condition of the entries. Nevertheless, Warner chose to embark on the nine-hour journey to the fair with his giant pumpkin.

Judges at the Port Elgin Pumpkinfest ruled that this soft spot led to the disqualification of Warner’s giant pumpkin from the heaviest pumpkin contest. (Submitted by Jeff Warner)
“I was committed to attending the event regardless of the outcome,” Warner remarked. “I figured I had a 50/50 chance of disqualification, so I thought let’s take it — it’s enjoyable to share the pumpkin with people on the highway; that’s part of the fun of the trip.”
Warner attempted to scrape the soft spot in an effort to halt the decay. However, with each stop he made, he noticed that the hole was increasing in size.
“I realized I was losing the fight, and I was simply hoping to still qualify for the competition,” Warner noted.
Upon reaching the festival, he learned the damage was irreversible. A judge informed him that the hole could not exceed three inches in diameter for the pumpkin to be eligible.
“He measured it and said, ‘No, it’s too large for the rules,'” Warner recounted. “I’m disappointed, but I completely understand that rules are in place for a reason.”
The pumpkin that ultimately claimed the top prize, according to Warner, weighed 1,542 pounds — nearly 170 pounds lighter than his impressive six-by-six foot, waist-high giant.
Despite this setback, Warner expresses no regrets about the long, hot July evenings he dedicated to nurturing his giant pumpkins, from pruning to watering.

Warner transported his 1,711-pound pumpkin on a trailer, making a nine-hour journey with hopes of winning the top award at this year’s Port Elgin Pumpkinfest. (Submitted by Jeff Warner)
“As time passes, I’m trying to surpass myself — to grow a larger pumpkin each year than before.”
Although his pumpkin didn’t secure the top award at the fair, Warner notes that it continues to attract interest. He mentions that families have been stopping by to admire his giant gourd and take photos alongside it.
Moreover, he has future plans for his pumpkin, which will serve a different purpose — a few hours to the north.
“My intention is to take it a couple of hours north to a polar habitat where we will feed it to the polar bears,” Warner shared.


