Prime Minister Mark Carney has rejected a series of recent remarks made by U.S. cabinet members that question the Liberal government’s rationale for exiting trade negotiations last month.
“With all due respect, I don’t believe that appointed, unelected cabinet officials in the United States are authorities on Canadian politics,” he stated in Thunder Bay, Ontario, on Thursday.
Since the withdrawal of Canada’s negotiating team back to Ottawa on Friday, August 21, Carney and Canada’s chief trade negotiator Janice Charette have consistently asserted that Canada departed after the U.S. introduced last-minute revisions that the government found to be unfair and economically unviable.
Carney has indicated that these changes would have limited Canada’s capacity to forge trade agreements with other nations, undermined cultural protections for the French language, and gradually harmed the auto sector.
“There were several points the United States insisted on until the very end: red lines that were non-negotiable. It was a take-it-or-leave-it approach. Now it seems they have changed their stance,” Carney remarked.
“Suddenly, they seem indifferent to Canadian language and cultural issues. If that were truly the case, they should not have included them in the agreement in the first place.”
This represents a stark contrast to the narrative being conveyed by the Trump administration since the failure of the deal.
Carney emphasizes the need for the U.S. to acknowledge Canada’s red lines
“We had an agreement, we shook hands, the president announced it, and the response was overwhelmingly positive. Canada chose to withdraw for political reasons; it’s purely a political matter,” U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick stated last week.
“If you think I ever mentioned the word French, you’re mistaken. Why would it matter to America how the Québécois communicate? We simply don’t care,” he added. “The fact is, we never raised those issues; it’s all fabricated.”
Lutnick claimed that the concerns regarding the French language were “manufactured” to influence the outcome of the Quebec election and to ensure federalists triumph in the upcoming Alberta plebiscite regarding an independence referendum.
U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, the Trump administration official who led the negotiations, also contested Ottawa’s claim that last-minute U.S. requests caused the breakdown of the trade agreement.
In an interview with CBC News chief political correspondent Rosemary Barton, Greer stated that near the end of the negotiations, Canada “had some additional perspectives. They had some further requests. Some of these were beyond what the United States could accommodate.”
-
Exclusive
What went wrong with U.S. trade talks, according to Canada’s chief negotiator
-
Carney says Trump and his cabinet should stop ‘throwing shade’ and get serious about a deal
Carney dismissed these interpretations of events and outlined what he requires to see before Canada considers re-entering negotiations with the Trump administration.
<p“Some of what they are currently stating contradicts the positions they took during the negotiations, and we will always advocate for what is in Canada’s best interest,” he asserted.
The prime minister indicated that for negotiations with the U.S. to resume, he seeks a deal that is sustainable in the long term and advantageous for both Canada and the United States.
“We are prepared to engage in discussions when the Americans are ready,” he stated.
This will occur, according to Carney, once the U.S. acknowledges and respects Canada’s red lines.
“Our stance is unequivocal. We must retain the right to protect and promote the French language, as well as Canadian and Quebec cultures. This is fundamental,” he emphasized. “We need to preserve our sovereignty to negotiate trade agreements with other countries.”



