This article is part of a broader investigation carried out by an international group of journalists associated with The Outlaw Ocean Project, a news organization based in Washington, D.C.
In 2020, a group of state investigators in Goa, India, visited a facility known as United Marine Products to assess its methods of disposing of toxic wastewater.
Residents in the area had voiced concerns for years, claiming that the factory was polluting the air and rendering their drinking water unsafe. The facility produces fish meal, a protein-dense powder created by grinding and cooking wild-caught fish, primarily for aquaculture feed.
Inspectors quickly uncovered that the operators of the plant had resorted to an illegal method of wastewater disposal by drilling boreholes into the soil in a field behind the facility. Authorities ultimately determined that these boreholes likely polluted groundwater, leading to illness among local residents and livestock.

The United Marine Products facility in Councolim, Goa, India. In 2020, investigators found that the plant had drilled holes into the ground behind the facility to illegally dispose of wastewater from fish meal processing. (Changing Markets Foundation)
The owner of the plant refuted any allegations of misconduct.
Consumers of seafood in Canada may feel detached from such distant issues.
However, this Indian facility was a supplier for Skretting, a prominent feed manufacturer utilized by numerous fish farms in Canada — meaning its products could be part of the salmon from British Columbia and New Brunswick or the trout from Quebec found in local grocery stores.
A five-year investigation by The Outlaw Ocean Project revealed a multitude of hidden costs associated with producing this feed, including the loss of traditional fishing jobs, ongoing chemical exposure, preventable fatalities among workers, and violent protests triggered by the overwhelming odors emitted by fish meal factories.
These social and environmental repercussions are mainly borne by poorer nations where the feed ingredients are harvested and processed, far removed from the affluent markets that consume the resulting seafood.

A worker unloads a crate of anchovies from a boat at the port of El Callao, Peru. Peru, the world’s largest fishmeal producer, is facing increasing concerns over overfishing and pollution from its fishmeal sector. (Rodrigo Abd/The Associated Press)
Whether sourced locally or imported, popular varieties of farmed seafood in Canada — such as salmon, shrimp, trout, sea bass, and sea bream — are often fed fish meal, derived from the very species of wild fish that aquaculture claims to be protecting, thereby exacerbating ocean depletion, according to fisheries experts.
“An accurate assessment of aquaculture’s true impact must begin not with the farm, but rather with the feed,” stated Daniel Pauly, project director of the Sea Around Us initiative at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver.
“This type of evaluation presents a significantly different perspective than what the industry portrays.”
Canada’s dependence on global fish meal
Since 2022, over half of the seafood consumed worldwide has originated from aquaculture rather than wild capture, according to the UN Food and Agriculture Organization. The aquaculture sector is valued at $444 billion and is the fastest-growing segment of global food production. Most of these fish farms rely on fish meal and fish oil derived from wild fish extracted from the ocean.
In contrast to cultivating bivalves such as oysters, clams, and mussels — which generally do not need additional feed — the primary challenge with raising carnivorous seafood like salmon and trout lies in providing them with adequate nourishment.

A worker operates a tractor near piles of fish meal made from menhaden fish, utilized as animal feed supplements in Reedville, Va., in 2015. (Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP/Getty Images)
Canada boasts over 200 fish farms, the majority of which depend on fish meal or fish oil, sourced domestically from Pacific anchoveta, chub mackerel, herring, haddock, pollock, sardines, and frigate tuna.
Canadian regulations prohibit vessels from targeting fish solely for the purpose of producing fish meal or fish oil, thus domestic fish meal is commonly produced using byproducts like skin and bones from processing that would otherwise be discarded. This is generally regarded as a more sustainable method for generating feed protein compared to utilizing whole fish that are fit for human consumption.
Nonetheless, approximately two-thirds of the fish meal utilized in Canada, particularly by aquaculture facilities — about 53,000 tonnes in 2023 — is imported, linking Canadian consumers to these overseas social costs. Additionally, Canada imports over $4 billion worth of seafood annually, with a third of that being primarily farmed salmon and shrimp, which heavily depend on fish meal and fish oil.
Food for Feed investigation
The Outlaw Ocean Project’s five-year investigation mapped nearly the entire global fish meal sector, identifying more than 1,400 fish meal facilities across 64 nations, tracing supply chains from fishing vessels to processing plants, feed mills, fish farms, and seafood retailers.
This reporting initiative involved numerous journalists from various countries who visited factories and farms and boarded fish meal vessels at sea.
In Gambia and Mauritania, the investigation highlighted how the industry contributes to food insecurity as fish that once nourished local populations are redirected to fish meal factories for export.

Workers organize the catch aboard the China-flagged Lu Lao Yuan Yu 010 in Gambian waters in 2019. When reporters from Outlaw Ocean boarded the vessels, they recorded widespread grievances regarding poor living and working conditions. (Fábio Nascimento/The Outlaw Ocean Project)
In India and Peru, the investigation revealed a connection to at least 80 protests, some of which turned violent, arising from issues like water pollution or the foul odors emanating from factories processing thousands of tonnes of rotting fish. Canada is the largest importer of fish oil from Peru.
In the Xinjiang region of China, the reporting exposed the presence of forced labor on fish farms.
The investigation mapped out over 1,000 fish farms in Xinjiang and Tibet — two regions facing intense state repression — that produce an estimated half-billion dollars’ worth of farmed seafood each year, some of which is sent to the United States and Canada.

A worker distributes fishmeal pellets into pens at a fish farm in Thailand in 2021. Over half of the seafood consumed globally originates from fish farms. (Mako Kurokawa)
‘Overexploited’ or worse
The investigation examined more than 2,400 vessels involved in fish meal production across at least 30 nations. It revealed that the majority of these ships do not fully adhere to the Global Charter for Fisheries Transparency, a framework established by ocean-focused civil society organizations that outlines accountability standards for industrial fishing fleets.
For instance, fewer than 30 percent of the fleet had publicly accessible location data, and less than 25 percent possessed a unique vessel identification number (akin to a ship’s license plate). This lack of transparency complicates enforcement efforts.
-
A third of global fishing goes unreported, UBC researchers find
-
Somalis say foreign ships are stealing their fish, and it’s fuelling a piracy resurgence
At least half of the species caught by the evaluated fish meal vessels were categorized by scientific studies as “overexploited” or worse — including flat and round sardinella in Senegal, oil sardines in India, and anchoveta in Chile.
The majority of the vessels in the global fish meal fleet are purse seiners or trawlers, employing large nets to capture dense schools of fish, which can inadvertently ensnare bycatch and non-target species.
At least 165 ships within the fleet were bottom trawlers, a harmful gear type that scrapes the ocean floor using weighted nets.
Fish meal reliance declining, industry says
In response to inquiries from The Outlaw Ocean Project about the sustainability of fish meal, the IFFO, the international fish meal association, stressed that its “role is not to dictate which markets should utilize fish meal and fish oil.”
Véronique Jamin, a spokesperson for the organization, remarked that fish farming is “the most efficient animal protein system” and is becoming increasingly efficient over time.

Bags of fish meal stored at a factory in Lima on December 3, 2009. While the aquaculture sector claims it has reduced its dependency on fish meal overall, some companies have seen increased demand as they expand. (Ernesto Benavides/AFP/Getty Images)
When asked about overfishing linked to the fish meal industry, Jamin stated, “Because small pelagics are rapidly renewable stocks, their sustainable harvesting limits are much higher than for slower-growing species like cod, tuna, or deep-sea fish.”
The feed and aquaculture sectors have claimed they are lessening their reliance on fish meal and fish oil by integrating alternative ingredients, including insects, algae, and krill. Between 2000 and 2020, the proportion of fish meal in global aquaculture feed decreased from 23 percent to eight percent, according to IFFO.
Producers of salmon, which generally requires larger amounts of fish meal and oil to thrive, assert they have also made advancements. Members of the Canadian Aquaculture Industry Alliance, including major producers like Cermaq and Mowi, reported reducing the share of these ingredients in salmon feed to below 20 percent, as noted in a November 2025 press release.
“These findings indicate that salmon farming enterprises have implemented science-based strategies that have enhanced the overall sustainability standards of salmon farming in Canada,” stated Timothy Kennedy, president of the Canadian Aquaculture Industry Alliance, in the release.

A salmon farm near Campbell River, B.C., during a routine health examination in 2018. (Jonathan Hayward/The Canadian Press)
Nonetheless, as aquaculture expands, so too does the demand for fish meal.
For instance, to satisfy demand, five of the largest salmon companies globally have increased their absolute consumption of fish meal or fish oil derived from whole wild fish by up to 39 percent from 2020 to 2024, according to a report from the Farm Animal Investment Risk and Return Initiative.
Two of these salmon companies with increased usage of fish meal have operations in Canada: Mowi, which announced in June 2025 its sale of Canadian farms to Cooke; and Grieg Seafood, whose Canadian operations were subsequently acquired by Cermaq. (Mowi, Cermaq, Cooke, and Grieg Seafood did not respond to requests for comments.)
Skretting initiates investigation
As of 2025, Canada had at least seven facilities producing fish meal and fish oil, and these sites are not without challenges.
Between 2021 and 2024, at least two of these facilities were linked to pollution or unsustainable fishing practices, according to Bait to Plate, an online resource created by The Outlaw Ocean Project that monitors the fishing and seafood sectors. Neither company replied to the project’s request for comment.
However, the significant burdens of food insecurity, depleted fish stocks, social unrest, and environmental pollution are primarily faced by the poorer nations that produce the fish meal or farmed seafood that Canada imports.
For instance, Canada sources over a third of its shrimp from India, where the investigation uncovered incidents of explosions, fires, and worker suffocations at fish meal facilities supplying the country’s shrimp farms.

Freshly harvested live shrimp at a shrimp farm in India, April 11, 2025. (Sahiba Chawdhary/Reuters)
As recently as 2022, United Marine Products, the Goan fish meal facility that was found to be illegally discharging wastewater, provided fish meal to Skretting Canada, which produces feed for many of Canada’s fish farms.
At another factory known as Bismi Aquatic Products in 2021, a migrant worker died while cleaning a wastewater tank and succumbed to toxic fumes. Major shrimp brands like IFC and AZ Gems, which source a significant portion of their shrimp from India, are available in Canada at major supermarket chains such as Metro Canada, Loblaws, and Costco Canada.
Skretting maintains a “zero-tolerance policy” for violations of its protocols, which explicitly require business partners to comply with all relevant laws and regulations governing their operations, stated the company’s Sustainability and Communications Director, Jorge Diaz, and has launched an investigation to validate the findings from this reporting.
In response to inquiries from Outlaw Ocean, Metro representative Stephanie Bonk stated: “All Metro suppliers are required to adhere to working conditions throughout the supply chain as outlined in our Supplier Code of Conduct for responsible procurement.”
IFC, AZ Gems, and Loblaws did not respond to a request for comment.


