The implementation of Ontario’s new cash bail system has been paused while a judge considers a challenge regarding its constitutionality.
An injunction was issued on Monday by the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and the Criminal Lawyers’ Association after their legal representatives and those from the province presented their cases last week.
Earlier this month, the new regulations went into effect, mandating individuals accused of crimes and granted bail to pay a cash security deposit within two business days of their release.
Previously, a financial deposit was only necessary if the release conditions were violated and a court ordered the payment.
The legal organizations contend that this alteration encroaches on federal authority and contradicts the Criminal Code, which they argue clearly instructs courts to prioritize a promise to pay over a cash payment.
They assert that this transition will effectively make it more challenging to secure bail, particularly for marginalized individuals who may lack the funds for a deposit or the ability to find a surety with adequate financial resources.

Earlier this month, the new regulations went into effect, requiring individuals accused of crimes and granted bail to pay a cash security deposit within two business days of their release. (CBC News)
On the other hand, the province claims this is merely an administrative modification that does not alter the conditions of release. It argues that the challenge is based on “speculation” regarding the potential effects of the new cash bail system.
Judge warns of potential harm if injunction is denied
In his ruling on Monday, Ontario Superior Court Justice William Chalmers expressed that he believes the legal organizations have demonstrated the possibility of irreparable harm if the injunction is not granted during his deliberation on the case.
“The impact of the contested legislation may lead to individuals who would otherwise be released facing denial or delay of their release due to challenges in securing a willing and able surety,” he stated.
-
Legal groups challenge Ontario’s new cash bail system in court
-
Legal groups question constitutionality of Ontario’s new cash bail system
“I am also convinced that granting the injunction would not harm the province,” he added. “The established status quo, which has been in place for over 50 years, will remain during the brief period before my decision regarding the constitutionality of the legislation is issued.”
The organizations expressed their approval of the ruling in a statement.
A representative for Attorney General Doug Downey remarked that the provincial government will not apologize for its attempts to reform the bail system.
“We are utilizing every available resource to make bail more impactful in order to safeguard victims and communities,” Julia Facca stated via email. “As this issue is currently before the court, we have no additional comments.”

