A judge from the Quebec Superior Court has ruled in favor of Cardinal Marc Ouellet in a defamation case against Paméla Groleau, mandating that she pay him $100,000 in damages.
Ouellet initiated the lawsuit contending that Groleau harmed his reputation, dignity, and honor after she implicated him in a 2022 class-action lawsuit that accused members of the Archdiocese of Quebec of sexual misconduct.
Groleau claimed to have met the cardinal multiple times between 2008 and 2010 while training or serving as a lay pastoral agent for the Catholic Church, alleging that Ouellet exhibited various forms of inappropriate behavior towards her, including unwanted touching.
She initially reported her allegations anonymously to a church advisory committee in 2008 and later submitted a formal complaint to Pope Francis in 2021, which was dismissed in 2022— the same year she became involved in the class action.
Justice Martin Castonguay found the allegations to be unconvincing, ruling against Groleau’s account.
-
Lawyer for Quebec Cardinal Marc Ouellet says accuser’s testimony lacks credibility
-
Witness recounts feeling like a ‘prisoner’ in 1992 encounter with Quebec cardinal
In his 52-page ruling issued on Monday, Castonguay stated that Groleau acted “recklessly or even with malice” towards the cardinal, failing to behave as a “reasonable person” would.
The judge noted that Groleau, frustrated with how her complaint to Pope Francis was managed, chose to modify her narrative to gain public attention.
He highlighted that the evidence clearly indicated the accusations were baseless and that Groleau herself eventually acknowledged considering only one of the claimed interactions as sexual assault.
“In relation to that particular incident, Groleau admitted to having changed her story to assert that Cardinal Ouellet touched her buttocks, fully understanding that most people would interpret this as contact with the curvature of the buttocks,” Castonguay wrote, “which was not the reality, nor was it in her previous accounts.”
Groleau, according to the judge, showed a complete disregard for Ouellet’s rights, including his right to maintain a good reputation, when she accused him of sexual misconduct in August 2022.
He indicated that Ouellet’s reputation suffered further due to the fact that the class action against the Archdiocese of Quebec predominantly involved clergy or lay individuals accused of pedophilia.
In his ruling, he clarified that four criteria must be satisfied to support a defamation claim, which include false assertions, irrelevant allegations to the matter at hand, claims made with malice or such recklessness that it equates to malice, and claims made without reasonable justification.
Court acknowledged the ‘injustice’ faced by Ouellet, lawyers assert
During the March trial, Justin Wee, representing Groleau, contended that his client did not defame Ouellet as her allegations were truthful and she had no intention to harm him.
Wee also argued that the media coverage related to the case could not be blamed on her.
On Monday, Groleau’s lawyers informed Radio-Canada that they would refrain from commenting and did not specify whether they would appeal the ruling.
Dominique Ménard, a managing partner at LCM Avocats, the law firm for Ouellet, released a statement on Monday expressing satisfaction that the court recognized the injustice Cardinal Ouellet endured, affirming that the wrong done to him now warrants reparation.
The statement emphasized that the ruling reaffirms that, even within judicial contexts, “serious allegations must be grounded in accurate and pertinent facts, articulated with the rigor their severity demands.”
In a separate statement on Tuesday, Ouellet expressed gratitude to his lawyers and the numerous witnesses who testified, acknowledging their contribution in helping “the court ascertain the facts and ensure that the truth prevailed.”
He vowed to persist in combating all forms of abuse, both within the Church and in broader society.
“I wholeheartedly support validated victims in their quest for restorative justice,” he stated.
Ouellet reiterated his commitment to donating any amount awarded from the lawsuit to organizations dedicated to fighting sexual abuse against Indigenous peoples in Canada.

